Latest News

What are battle lines in Ireland's multi-billion euro Russian jet trial?

The opening salvos have been fired in a 2.5 billion euro ($ 2.7 billion), Irish court fight between some of the world's biggest airplane lessors and their insurance providers over around 80 jets stranded in Russia.

Dublin's High Court previously this month started to hear the case that attorneys included expect to take numerous months.

Here are the main arguments set out by the 2 sides:

ARE THE AIRCRAFTS LOST?

Lessors crossed out billions of euros from their balance sheets after Russian airline companies stopped working to return their airplane and they state there is no genuine prospect of recovery. However some insurance companies argue the jets may be returned in the future which lessors have suffered a paper loss instead of a physical. loss.

Insurers argue the suits are early and have pointed. to lessors' settlements with Russia over a few of the caught. jets, which have actually totalled more than $2.5 billion to date.

WHAT TRIGGERED THE LOSS?

A main point in the event is whether the actions of the. Russian government were the principal reason for the failure by. airline companies to return the planes or whether the desire of the. airlines to retain ownership played a part.

That could identify whether claims should be made under the. narrower war danger or broader all dangers policies and whether. a valid claim can be made under either policy at all, lawyers. stated.

WHEN DID THE LOSSES START?

Insurance companies' notifications withdrawing war-risk cover for Russia. began to take effect from March 8. However a lawyer representing. lessors said clients were already in the grip of the danger. before this date, arguing that the loss had currently efficiently. happened.

Lessors indicate their mainly unproductive attempts to. reclaim the planes, that began as soon as EU sanctions were. adopted on Feb. 25, 2022. Attorneys for a few of the insurance providers have. accused the plaintiffs of failing to specify a date when the. loss occurred.

WHAT ARE THE PERTINENT INSURANCE POLICIES?

Legal representatives for insurance companies argued that if a loss occurred, the. primary relevant insurance policy is that held by the airline. renting the airplane which any claim need to be made with. those, generally Russian, insurance providers.

Lessors argue that their efforts to secure claims under. those policies have actually failed, however insurers in the case counter. that this route is far from tired.

Lessors state their claims need to be paid under contingent. cover that they say must step in if policies held by the. Russian airline companies fail to pay. They have also suggested. claims could come under possessed cover, which covers threats. during repossession of an airplane.

(source: Reuters)