Latest News

Trump says wind and solar are bad for the grid. Texas proves otherwise

Donald Trump claims the rapid adoption of solar power and wind energy has caused U.S. electricity to be unstable and expensive. This is why he wants to stop most subsidies for renewable energies.

According to price and regulatory data, the grid in Texas that has the most renewable energy is more reliable and the electricity prices are lower than the national average. Some grids, which rely on fossil fuel generation for a large part of their power, have faced reliability problems and soared prices.

According to its reliability assessment of June 6, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, the main grid operator of Texas, predicts that there is only a 0.30 percent chance of rolling blackouts in August during peak energy demand. This is a huge improvement over the 12% probability it had predicted for August 2024.

According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration's latest monthly report, the average electricity price for Texas residents and businesses is about 10 cents a kilowatt-hour, which is 24% lower than the national average.

Joshua Rhodes is a researcher at the University of Texas, Austin. He said that ERCOT had done a great job in defining products for energy and reliability. It could serve as a model for other grids on how to achieve reliability at low cost.

The Texas grid's performance refutes the assumptions that drove Trump's tax and spending bill, passed by Congress last week. This bill will end subsidies for solar, wind, and other clean technologies.

In a post on social media, U.S. Energy Sec. Chris Wright praised the bill's cuts. He said it "will help to end wasteful subsides and deliver more reliable electricity for the American people!"

Trump signed Monday his latest executive orders directing federal agencies that the One Big Beautiful Bill repeal or modify tax credit for solar and wind project. Trump called renewable energy expensive and unreliable. He claimed that renewables were replacing more reliable sources, relied upon foreign-controlled supply chain and damaged the environment.

Solar and wind energy only works when the sun shines or the wind blows. Intermittence can lead to significant shortages in periods of high demand.

The Texas power grid, while it has experienced major failures, not all of them were due to renewable energy.

Natural gas pipelines and wellheads froze in February 2021 during an unusual cold snap. This caused blackouts, which left millions of Texans without electricity for days.

Texas has invested heavily in large-scale storage facilities to store excess power generated by wind, solar and other generators. According to ERCOT’s resource adequacy report reviewed by, these battery storage facilities release power when needed. They have also helped to reduce the likelihood of blackouts in this year.

ERCOT has said that it has added more than 5 gigawatts in battery storage since summer 2024. This brings the total capacity to over 8 gigawatts. ERCOT says that another 174 gigawatts will be connected over the next five year.

ERCOT has declined to comment on Trump’s assertion that renewables are unstable for the grid.

Garrett Golding is an assistant vice-president of energy programs for the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. He said that increasing capacity through solar and battery storage has been a successful combination for the Texas grid in the last two years. "I doubt that it is applicable to all states, even those with similar climates."

The White House didn't respond to a request for comment.

BETTER THAN OTHERS

Grids that rely on fossil fuels can suffer from reliability and cost issues.

The PJM interconnection, the U.S.'s largest regional grid, is heavily reliant on fossil fuels. Its electricity prices are rising while its reliability is declining.

Tom Bullock is the executive director of Citizens Utility Board of Ohio. This consumer watchdog group said that "the grid is an old pickup truck with multiple pressures on it."

State regulators in Ohio, a major market within PJM territory, expect that electricity prices will increase by more than 20 percent this year.

PJM generated nearly 60% of its electricity last year from natural gas and coal. According to PJM, wind and solar accounted for about 6% of PJM's electricity generation.

Bullock and consumer advocates warned that Trump's rejection to renewables would only increase the price of electricity, rather than control it. This is especially true as data centers and electric cars are increasing their demand for power.

The U.S. Department of Energy released an analysis this week that predicted significant electricity blackouts on PJM territory over the next five-year period, if there is no massive new generation.

The DOE report stated that in a worst case scenario, PJM may have over 1,000 hours per year when the electricity production is not enough to meet demand. PJM refused to comment on DOE's report.

ERCOT's time was only 149 hours according to the DOE's worst case analysis.

Ben Dietderich, DOE spokesperson said: "The report acknowledges that ERCOT is improving in its efforts to address grid vulnerabilities."

Frank Rambo is the executive director of Horizon Climate Initiative. A non-profit organization that advocates cutting fossil fuel production, Rambo fears Trump's policy will upset years of planning done by utilities, grid operators, and state commissions to add renewable sources of energy.

Rambo stated, "It has destabilization written on it." (Reporting and editing by Richard Valdmanis, David Gregorio and Tim McLaughlin)

(source: Reuters)