Latest News

US judge questions Justice Department on efforts to return a wrongly deported person

A U.S. Judge expressed frustration Friday over the failure of President Donald Trump's Administration to provide enough details about their efforts to bring back an American man who was sent to prison in El Salvador after being deported by mistake.

At a hearing, U.S. district judge Paula Xinis stated that the government did not provide information from high-level official that explained adequately how it was following her order to “facilitate” the return of Maryland resident Kilmar Abrego Garcia.

The Trump administration has argued the details sought by Abrego Garcia’s attorneys are confidential secrets of state, but Xinis claimed the Justice Department hadn't shown how this doctrine would be applied.

The judge stated, "You haven't given me enough information to be able to say, 'Ok I get it, I know what the government thinks of the plaintiffs requests or court order poses a reasonable risk to diplomatic relations'."

Xinis claimed that the information given by government officials to Abrego Garcia in his case had been "a exercise in utter disappointment."

Andrew Rossman, Abrego Garcia’s lawyer, told Xinis that it was "deeply troubling" to hear the administration claim it was following the judge's order while "the highest officials of the government say the opposite."

The hearing in Greenbelt is the latest court battle over Abrego Garcia's deportation. There are concerns that the Administration failed to comply with Xinis orders, even though the U.S. Supreme Court stated it "should share what it could concerning the steps it had taken" to facilitate Abrego's return.

Abrego Garca was deported from El Salvador to El Salvador despite a court order that protected him. Democrats and legal analysts are concerned about his case, as they believe that Trump's government is willing to ignore the judiciary branch of government.

Xinis ordered last month that the administration provide more information on what it is doing to ensure Abrego Garcia’s return. She had previously stated that the administration hadn't given her any useful information about its efforts.

Officials in the administration have accused courts for interfering with executive branch foreign policy.

The government has invoked state secrets privilege to hide details of its attempts to return Abrego Garca. This legal doctrine allows the government the right to prevent the disclosure information that may harm national security.

In a filing to a federal court this week, the U.S. Department of Justice stated that Abrego Garcia’s lawyers had "all the necessary information" for them to confirm compliance with the court’s order regarding his return. Blake Brittain in Washington and Mike Scarcella, editors David Bario and Deepa Babyington.

(source: Reuters)