Latest News

Uber and Lyft won court ruling on NYC law that requires notice before terminating drivers

Federal judge rules that New York City can't prohibit?Uber Technologies or Lyft from deactivating their drivers without prior notice. The novel law, he says, is unconstitutional. U.S. District Judge Gregory Woods, in Manhattan, said in a written ruling on Tuesday that New York City's new law benefits only a small number of drivers and interferes with ride-hailing firms' rights to monitor the safety of their platforms.

Woods wrote that "Uber and Lyft will likely succeed in proving that the law only protects a small class of drivers, and does not advance broader economic or social interests which the Constitution requires for allowing 'the severe impairment of contracts. The judge issued an injunction to prevent the city from enforcing the law. It was scheduled to go into effect on July 28.

In a statement released by a Lyft spokesperson, the company said that it was "pleased" the court acknowledged the "serious safety issues at the core of this challenge."

Uber's spokesman Josh Gold added: "The opinion highlights that driver fairness can and must go together with rider safety."

New York City Law Department has not responded to comments immediately. The law was one of the first in the 'U.S. after the New York City Council overruled a veto from former mayor Eric Adams. Adams had said that the new law would create a costly and unwieldy bureaucracy in order to 'handle claims of wrongful deactivation.

Ride-hailing companies must give drivers a 14-day notice before they are deactivated from their apps. However, there is an exception made for "egregious misconduct." They may also rehire deactivated drivers since 2019 because they did not receive this notice.

In lawsuits filed a few days apart, Uber and Lyft claimed that the law violated their constitutional rights to due process and free speech. They said that the law would undermine their goodwill and reputation while allowing unsafe drivers to continue on the roads, including those who have been accused of sexual misconduct.

(source: Reuters)