Latest News

Beumer sues EU antitrust regulators over Vanderlande, Siemens deal, court filing shows

A court filing seen by revealed that the German logistics group Beumer Group has taken EU antitrust regulators 'to 'court' for refusing to investigate Dutch rival Vanderlandes' acquisition of Siemens' airport logistic 'unit'.

Beumer was concerned when Siemens announced the EUR300m ($341.31m) deal with Dutch luggage conveyor belts and package-sorting systems Vanderlande owned by Japan's Toyota Industries two years ago.

In March of this year, Vanderlande asked regulators in Portugal & Spain to approve the deal. These?countries and Italy then asked the European Commission (EC) to take on the case.

In May, the EU's competition enforcer rejected these requests.

The Commission stated that the requests were not "appropriate" for the EU, as the deal has been in place 'for more than one year. The Commission said that Portugal and Spain must continue to investigate the case as national agencies are regularly scrutinising the market.

Beumer argued in court that the Commission had erred by failing to evaluate the deal. The company urged the court to void its decision.

The Commission does not have the discretion to deny a request for a referral when it is obvious, on the basis of objective criteria that the national competition authorities (NCAs), who are requesting the referral, will be unable to effectively review the concentration. This was stated in the July 17 filing.

Beumer stated that the EU's decision was also based upon criteria that were not legally relevant.

A spokesperson for the Commission said, "As always, the Commission is?ready to defend its decisions in Court."

The General Court in Luxembourg usually takes several years to hear a case.

(source: Reuters)