Latest News

US rail fuel surcharges for grain have reached record levels, pinching farmers during harvest season

The railroad fuel surcharges on U.S. grain shipment have more than doubled in the last year. This has impacted the entire farm belt, increasing transportation costs at a time when many farmers are also struggling with higher production costs.

According to U.S. Department of Agriculture statistics, the average fuel surcharge on grain shipments rose to 48 cents per mile for rail cars in the second?week of September. This is a?153% increase compared to the weighted averaging rate a year ago. Surcharges are used by railroads to recover the majority of fuel costs and add them to long-haul rates.

According to the USDA report of September 10, surcharges for corn and soybeans shipping accounted for 11%, up from 5%, in total costs.

Farmers are facing a particularly difficult time, as corn and soybean harvests have just begun. The U.S. War with Iran is driving crude oil and refined products prices higher. Diesel fuel surcharges will become a larger part of grain transportation costs as demand for transportation increases.

When railroads pass on excess costs to?shippers such as grain elevators who buy from farmers and then ship grain by rail the basis for growers is usually weaker, meaning that they get a lower price for their crops when they sell them.

Gary Millershaski is a Kansas wheat and sorghum producer and the chairman of U.S. Wheat Associates, a group that promotes exports, reported the basis of his local grain elevator at around 70 cents below Chicago Board of Trade K.C. Hard wheat futures are usually 40 cents below the Chicago Board of Trade K.C.

Millershaski stated, "We don?t even like to look at that because it upsets us."

Brent oil futures soared above $104 per barrel last week. This was the highest price since mid-May. The increase in Brent oil prices is due to fears about an escalating Iran conflict. Diesel fuel, the fuel that locomotives use, has reached a new record price of $6 per gallon.

Frayne Olson is a crop economist at North Dakota State University and said that the rapid changes in fuel prices have caused "absolute conniptions" and fits.

When you consider an industry in which your profit margins are a few cents per bushel or less, it makes a big difference.

Olson stated that many?corn and soybean growers do not have access to inland waters and rely on railroads for long-distance transportation of crops to processors, terminals for export and feeding operations.

Everyone is very quick to increase fuel surcharges, but very, very slowly to lower them. This just gives them an opportunity to raise freight rates which further exacerbates our problem," said Steve Compton a Kansas farmer.

Fuel surcharges will be added to long-haul tariffs for railroads BNSF and CSX. Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific Kansas City, Canadian National and BNSF are also imposing fuel surcharges. CSX, Norfolk Southern and BNSF declined to respond to comments.

BILLIONS OF DOLLARS FOR BUSHELS

A spokesperson for Canadian Pacific said that railroads use surcharges to reduce their exposure to fuel price fluctuations.

Surcharges are tied to the U.S. On-Highway Diesel Fuel Index. The index is up by about 60% over the past year. They are triggered when fuel costs equal or exceed a strike-price that ranges in general between $2.30 per gallon and $3.25. Surcharges increase as the index increases.

Surface Transportation Board, which regulates the industry, reports that railroads collected fuel surcharges of $2.93 billion during the second quarter. This is an increase of more than 90% compared to the previous year's period. This covered approximately 90% of the diesel costs.

Canadian National's spokesperson said that surcharges ensure rates are fair and reflect current operating costs.

Analysts expect railroad surcharges will remain "higher" for the remainder of the year.

Archer-Daniels-Midland and other major shippers have not reported negative impacts from surcharges, according to their latest financial reports. ADM, for example, increased its forecasted profit by 10% last month as a result of rising oil prices.

Grain elevators owned by ADM or privately held Cargill factor in fuel and freight surcharges to the cash price, which can sometimes lower the prices farmers receive for grains. ADM and Cargill declined to comment.

Olson explained that during periods of high export demand, the transportation costs can shift and be passed onto buyers on key markets like China.

If Union Pacific purchases Norfolk Southern, transportation costs may increase. The railroads claim that this deal could improve service and streamline freight movement.

Farm groups are concerned that the merger will hurt the cash price of grains. Daniel Munch is an economist at the American Farm Bureau Federation (the leading U.S. agricultural lobby).

Attorneys General from major grain-producing states concur.

In a letter sent to the STB on August 11, officials from Iowa, Kansas and Montana, among other states, wrote: "There is absolutely no reason for a railroad to be so large that it will take money away from farmers, shippers, and consumers across the nation."

(source: Reuters)