Latest News

Families of crash victims appeal US Judge's decision to dismiss Boeing criminal charges

Families of victims of the two Boeing 737 MAX crashes in which 346 people died asked a U.S. court of appeals on Thursday to overturn a judge’s decision to allow the Justice Department to dismiss a criminal complaint against the planemaker.

Judge Reed O'Connor of the U.S. District Court Fort Worth, Texas last week approved the Justice Department's request, but harshly criticised the government's choice.

He did not believe that it was in the public's interest to dismiss the case which had initially been pursued by the Biden administration, and resulted in an initial admission of guilt.

The families requested that the 5th Circuit Court reverse his decision. The families claimed that the Justice Department had violated their rights when it reached a deferred prosecutor agreement with Boeing on a fraud charge arising from false statements the planemaker made to Federal Aviation Administration.

Paul Cassell is an attorney for some families. He said, "We don't believe the courts should be silent while injustices are committed." "The charges against Boeing can't be simply dropped."

Boeing did not respond immediately to a comment request on Thursday. Last week, the Justice Department rejected the judge's criticism. It said that it thought the deal was the "most just outcome."

O'Connor stated in 2023, "Boeing's crimes may be considered as the deadliest corporate crimes in U.S. history."

He claimed he did not have the authority to refuse the government's deal with Boeing even though the agreement "fails" to provide the accountability necessary to ensure the safety for the flying public.

Boeing agreed last year to plead guilty on a charge of criminal fraud conspiracy after the fatal 737 MAX crash in Indonesia and Ethiopia, in 2018 and 2019.

In May, after Donald Trump became president of the United States, the Justice Department changed its course and no longer demanded a guilty plea.

Boeing has agreed to pay $444.5 in addition to the $243.6 million fine, plus $455 million for the improvement of safety and compliance programs.

The FAA proposed fining Boeing $3 million in September for a number of safety violations. These included actions related to an Alaska Airlines 737 MAX-9 mid-air emergency that occurred on January 20, 2024, as well as for interfering the independence of safety officials.

A jury in Chicago ordered Boeing on Wednesday to pay over $28 million to Shikha Garg's family, an environmental worker for the United Nations who died in the crash. Boeing has agreed to not appeal the decision and will pay the $35.85million verdict plus 26% interest. (Reporting and editing by Leslie Adler, Jamie Freed, and David Shepardson)

(source: Reuters)