Latest News

The'shadow fleet of Russian oil tankers': Key facts

Western sanctions against Russia for its invasion of Ukraine, aimed at cutting down its oil revenue, have led to a massive "shadow fleet" (or shadow fleet) of tankers that help Moscow maintain its crude exports.

These unregulated vessels are a prime example of what you need to know.

Why is this fleet in the news? The UK imposed sanctions on an oil tanker that was sailing in international waters in the Baltic Sea between Estonia and Finland without a flag, which is against maritime regulations. Estonia tried to stop it, prompting Moscow's fighter jet to fly around it. Last week, the UK announced new sanctions against up to 100 tankers, which it described as "a key part of Vladimir Putin's (Russian president Vladimir) shadow fleet operation". The EU Commission also proposed similar measures against 100 vessels on top of the 153 previously sanctioned. The U.S. also has imposed several rounds of sanctions on the tankers transporting Russian oil.

VESSELS AGEING

The so-called "shadow fleet" transports Russian oil and includes hundreds of old tankers.

Shipping and insurance sources familiar with this matter said that the vessels are often opaquely owned and sail without top Western insurance or safety certification coverage. They also have unknown insurers or assessors for vessel seaworthiness, both of which are required for ocean going commercial ships.

These tankers are a common sight as they sail through the Baltic Sea, moving oil to the Gulf of Finland. This is a vital route for Russia's exports of energy.

NATO and EU regulators are keeping a close eye on the fleet, as new sanctions target vessels that have been blacklisted due to their involvement in Moscow's Ukraine war effort or for skirting price limits. Twelve Western countries, including Britain, Germany and Poland, as well as the Netherlands and five Nordic nations, agreed to "disrupt" and "deter" Russia's Shadow Fleet in response to several unexplained cables cuts and incidents in the Baltic Sea.

Britain, Denmark and Sweden are inspecting insurance documents for vessels in the Channel, Danish Straits, Gulf of Finland and the strait connecting Sweden and Denmark.

HOW DOES THE SHADOW FLEET OPERATE? Lloyd's List Intelligence, Finland's Coast Guard and other sources have stated that the shadow fleet employs tactics such as ship-to ship transfers in international waters where port control authorities are less vigilant. They also use falsification techniques, such as fake ship identification, spoofed data on location, and flag countries which offer lower oversight. The majority of tankers are also owned by shell firms in Dubai. They are bought and sold by anonymous or newly-formed firms. This complicates accountability. According to Norwegian authorities the fleet is largely comprised of old tankers that rely on non-Western insurance or fake insurance. This raises concerns over maintenance, safety and environmental standards.

Who's Cashing In and What's Being Done? The UK and France claim that Russia has been the biggest beneficiary of the sanctions. It is able to maintain oil exports in spite of the Western sanctions. This ensures steady revenues for its war against Ukraine. China and India are now the biggest buyers of Russian crude and benefit from steep discounts. They often purchase oil below the $60 per barrel cap imposed by the West, according to data on shipping and port loading. If ships use Western services, such as ports, insurance, or financing, they must show compliance with this price limit. Monitoring compliance can be difficult. Despite the fact that some tankers lost their insurance coverage due to suspected sanctions violations, many others continue to operate with other insurers or jurisdictions who are willing take on the risk. The shadow fleet is growing as new vessels replace the blacklisted ones. Documents show that more Russian insurers have emerged to offer alternative coverage for Russian oil shipments.

Western insurance sources claim that it is not clear how any claims settlement for an oil spill will work, given the banking sanctions.

The price cap has been offset by the rising global oil prices, and the shadow fleet is still operating with minimal disruption.

What are the risks?

Shadow fleets may be a threat to the environment, as they are often old, poorly-regulated tankers that are prone for spills, mechanical breakdowns and leaks. This can threaten marine ecosystems.

In December of last year, Russian authorities tried to stop the spillage of oil in the Kerch Strait caused by two damaged 50-year old tankers. The damage was caused during a stormy weekend. The spill may become one of the worst environmental disasters in the past few years to hit the region, but the extent of insurance claims is not yet known.

(source: Reuters)