Latest News

Former Trafigura top nickel trader denies collusion in $600 million fraud

In a London court on Monday, Trafigura’s former chief nickel trader denied accusations by Indian businessman Prateek gupta that he was involved in a $600-million fraud to exchange expensive metals with cheap or worthless ones.

Trafigura, a Geneva-based company, sued Gupta more than two years ago. It claimed that he was responsible for a fraud where he and his firms agreed to deliver high-quality nickel 99.8% pure but instead delivered scrap or steel.

Gupta based in Dubai has denied that Trafigura employees devised the plan, creating a complex merry go round of transactions which would appear to boost its status in nickel trading.

In a written statement, Sokratis ikonomou, the Trafigura nickel trader who was appointed head in 2017 told a London high court trial that he had not devised, known of or participated in such an arrangement.

"I find it insulting that you suggest I would compromise my integrity and risk my career in order to come up with and propose such an idea."

Trafigura terminated the employment of Trafigura's employee in January 2023, after approximately 16 years.

Evidence and Internal Probe

Gupta, his lawyers and Trafigura employees produced emails and chats in December 2023. He claims that these are proof that Gupta was not the only one involved in this operation.

Trafigura previously stated that it investigated whether its staff had colluded with Gupta but was satisfied with their denials.

Gupta stated that Oikonomou had proposed to increase nickel trading between Trafigura, Gupta’s firms and Trafigura to 50,000 tons per year in May 2019. Gupta replied by saying there wasn’t enough high-grade Nickel and suggested to include scrap and alloys.

Gupta claimed that Oikonomou refused to trade low-grade Nickel in the open because Trafigura’s bank Citi would finance only high-grade Nickel.

Citi declined to comment about the fraud case.

Gupta claimed that Oikonomou had proposed a "transit-financing" operation in which Gupta owned or affiliated companies would sell nickels to Trafigura, and other Gupta associated firms would purchase them when they arrived at the ports to ensure that others would not discover the substitute.

Trafigura acknowledges that both parties ran a transit finance operation but denies the scheme was designed to trade in secret low-grade metals or nickel.

Trafigura also admitted that it had paid for nickel it believed to be pure without verifying the authenticity. However, it said it was an oversight because it did not have valid documents or commodity codes.

Gupta is still subject to an asset freeze order, which he unsuccessfully tried to lift in December of 2023. (Reporting and editing by Louise Heavens, Eric Onstad)

(source: Reuters)