Latest News

Italian court rules against Sicily Bridge, but government wants to push on

The Italian court ruled plans for the largest suspension bridge in the world between Italy's mainland and Sicily's island would violate EU environmental and procurement rules. However, the government has said that it will not abandon the flagship project.

The government of Prime Minister Giorgia Melons says that the 3,666 metre bridge planned over the Strait of Messina, which is longer than the one in Turkey, will bring prosperity to the traditionally poorer areas and aid the movement of NATO troops. In a 33-page decision published late Thursday, the Court of Auditors stated that the government had failed to justify its disregard for environmental concerns regarding the impact of coastal and marine areas in the Calabria and island regions.

The proposed bridge is a subject of debate in the country for more than 50 years. Supporters tout its economic benefits, while critics point out wasteful spending and environmental damage to an area that is prone earthquakes.

The ruling stated that "the assumptions regarding the different'reasons for public interest' have not been validated by technical authorities and are not supported with adequate documentation," referring to the $13.5 billion ($15.65 million) project.

Costs Concerns

The judges noted that the uncertainty of costs and financing changes compared to a 2005 original contract, which was more than three-times cheaper, may require a tender in order to ensure European bidder rules are respected.

The Eurolink consortium, which has been selected for the construction of the bridge, is led by Webuild in Italy and includes Sacyr and IHI from Japan.

The government said that it would carefully review the ruling and promised to continue the project. Infrastructure Minister Matteo Salvini, who leads the League's far-right party, has made the project a top priority.

In a statement, the government said that it was "convinced" there is ample room to clarify these issues before the Court.

The consortium expressed "full faith" in the government's ability to address all concerns raised.

Meloni or Salvini could seek to have the cabinet overrule the court's objections if they are unable to convince it. However, this may trigger constitutional and legal challenges.

(source: Reuters)